Modern Search Marketing

Substack and SEO: Should Brands Be on the Platform?

Substack offers brands opportunities to connect with engaged audiences, but is it worth the investment? Explore how businesses are using the platform, what it means for SEO, and how to decide if it's right for your brand.

For most businesses, Substack probably shouldn’t be a marketing priority. However, it can offer interesting opportunities to build credibility, connect with niche audiences, and experiment with a more personal approach to content. The key is understanding what makes Substack different from traditional marketing channels and what it takes to succeed there. Let’s look at how brands are using the platform, what it means for search marketing, and how to decide if it’s worth your time and resources.

What Is Substack, and Why Are Brands Interested?

Substack is a publishing platform that allows creators to publish articles, podcasts, and videos to a community of subscribers. Readers can access content through their email inboxes, the Substack website, or its mobile app. The platform is free to use, with the option to offer paid subscriptions, of which Substack takes a 10% cut. 

Substack has caught the interest of brands that want a different approach to content marketing. The Substack community is highly engaged, and the platform feels like a return to old-school blogging with a wide array of thoughtful essays, original perspectives, and other editorial content. There are opportunities to have conversations and maintain relationships without relying entirely on search engines or social media algorithms. 

Should Brands Actually Be on Substack?

Brands are not prohibited from publishing, but Substack is not designed for traditional business marketing. It describes itself as “a place for independent writers, podcasters, and creators.” The content guidelines also state: 

“Substack is intended for high quality editorial content, not conventional email marketing. We don’t permit publications whose primary purpose is to advertise external products or services, drive traffic to third party sites, distribute offers and promotions, enhance search engine optimization, or similar activities. Brands and commercial organizations publishing on Substack may be subject to additional verification.” 

Ultimately, answering the question “should brands actually be on Substack” is tricky because it truly depends. Broadly speaking, Substack is not a typical platform for a business, but there are ways that it can work well and work authentically. 

How Are Brands Successfully Using Substack?

Brands that find their place on Substack offer content people genuinely want to read, even if those readers have no interest in purchasing their products or services. Compelling publications have a distinct personality, offer a unique perspective, and connect readers around shared interests. 

For example, restaurant loyalty company Blackbird publishes The Supersonic, which features food commentary, chef interviews, and personal essays about dining culture. Similarly, Ace Hotel’s Room With a View explores art, design, music, and travel through stories from its team and outside contributors, including a recurring column from writer Shama Rahman. Both publications explore subjects that are naturally connected to their brands without making their products or services the focus of every article.

Can B2B Brands Find an Audience on Substack?

Noteworthy examples of B2B brands on Substck tend to focus on individual expertise, original research, and conversations within specialized professional communities. Even in B2B marketing, the platform can be an opportunity for people to connect with others.

For example, financial technology company Ramp publishes Ramp Economics Lab, written by its lead economist, Ara Kharazian. The publication explores economic trends, AI adoption, and business spending using proprietary data from Ramp. While the content is connected to the company’s expertise, it’s presented through Kharazian’s perspective and offers information that business leaders and industry professionals may find valuable regardless of their interest in Ramp’s products.

Another example is Shopify’s In Stock, which shares founder interviews, entrepreneurship stories, and commerce insights through contributions from real people. Rather than focusing on product features, Shopify uses the publication to explore the experiences and challenges of building a business.

A slightly different example is Because of Marketing, a marketing and media brand. Its main website serves as a digital publication featuring marketing news, brand campaigns, interviews, and industry stories. Its Substack delivers weekly marketing roundups, offers paid content, and includes newsletter sponsorships.

Interestingly, brands don’t necessarily need to start their own publications to reach these audiences.

How Can Brands Participate Without Starting a Publication?

Instead of starting their own Substack, brands can participate in the community by sponsoring an existing newsletter or collaborating with writers through guest contributions, interviews, and other editorial partnerships. 

With a sponsorship, a brand pays to be featured in a publication that already reaches its target audience.  They might create a short sponsored message within a newsletter or embark upon a more creative collaboration with the writer. Guest contributions and interviews offer another opportunity for founders, executives, and industry experts to share their knowledge with an established readership.

Of course, the partnership needs to make sense for both the brand and the audience. Sponsored content should be clearly identified, and collaborations should respect the writer’s editorial voice and offer something genuinely valuable to readers.

Should You Use Substack Instead of a Blog or Email Marketing Platform?

Definitely not. A company website, an email marketing platform, and Substack serve different purposes. They can work together as part of a broader content strategy, but Substack is the lowest on the list for most businesses. 

Your website is generally the primary destination for information about your business, products, and services, as well as content designed to attract organic search traffic. Dedicated email marketing platforms offer tools for audience segmentation, automated campaigns, A/B testing, and integrations with CRM and ecommerce systems through APIs. Substack, in contrast, offers a more editorial experience focused on publishing content, building an audience, and maintaining relationships with readers. 

For most brands, a website with a blog and a dedicated email marketing solution are mandatory. Substack, however, is only worth considering when those existing channels are adequately resourced, performing well, and there’s additional time and creative bandwidth to dedicate to building a publication.

How Does Substack Affect SEO?

Substack isn’t a top strategy we’d recommend to clients to improve their SEO. However, when it is on the table, there are some important considerations to address: 

Can Substack articles rank on Google?

Yes! Public Substack articles can be indexed and appear in Google search results. Substack even offers built-in SEO tools, including customizable title tags and meta descriptions. Of course, ranking isn’t guaranteed.

Does publishing on Substack help your main website’s SEO?

Not directly. Your Substack content lives on a separate website, so any organic traffic it attracts goes there instead of to your company’s website. You may see indirect benefits through increased brand awareness, referral traffic, and mentions, but don’t expect Substack to automatically improve your website’s rankings.

Should you publish the same content on your website and Substack?

We wouldn’t recommend it as a regular strategy. Duplicate content doesn’t automatically result in a Google penalty, but Google generally chooses one version to prioritize in search results, and it might not be the one on your website. It’s best to give each platform a distinct purpose. 

What SEO best practices should you follow on Substack?

The same fundamentals that apply to traditional blogging! Conduct keyword research, write descriptive titles and headings, organize content logically, and link to credible sources.

Is Substack Worth the Investment for Your Business?

Whether or not Substack is worth it comes down to whether you have something interesting to contribute, an audience that wants to hear it, and the resources to make it worthwhile.

Yes, Substack is free to launch, but maintaining a publication requires a significant investment of time and creativity. Producing original content, growing an audience, and engaging with readers all take ongoing effort, and there’s no guarantee of a return.

There are also some risks and limitations to consider. Substack has restrictions on promotional content, and you’re ultimately publishing on a platform you don’t control. Although you can export your email list and content, it’s wise to maintain regular backups. If you decide to charge for subscriptions, Substack takes 10% of that revenue, plus applicable payment processing fees.

So, how do you decide whether it’s worth pursuing? Here’s a quick decision-making guide:

Discuss Content Strategy With Cadence SEARCH 

At Cadence SEARCH, we help businesses make informed decisions about where to invest their content marketing resources. Our team develops strategies that strengthen search visibility, build brand authority, and reach the right audiences across websites, social media, YouTube, email, and other channels. Contact us to discuss how we can help you make the most of your content marketing efforts.

—

References:

  1. https://substack.com/content
  2. https://www.thesupersonic.blackbird.xyz/
  3. https://acehotel.substack.com/
  4. https://econlab.substack.com/
  5. https://shopify.substack.com/
  6. https://becauseofmarketing.substack.com/
Turn Insight Into Action

Ready to Get Found in Modern Search?

Build a search strategy designed for Google, AI search, content discovery, and the channels influencing demand.

Book Your Free Strategy Session →